Get Your Free Cone


Under Christina Aguilera’s ‘Genie in a Bottle’ on YouTube, one of the top-rated comments says that what people dismissed as ‘soulless pop crap’ twenty-five years ago now sounds rich by comparison. Under Britney Spears’s ‘Boys’, another argues that Taylor Swift may outdo Britney on the commercial numbers but never ‘peaked’ the way she did.

Neither comment is really about a singer. The first is about a record that improved while sitting perfectly still. The second splits two things that usually get filed together: how much a song earned, and how far into everybody’s life it got.

At thirteen I was in a nightclub in rural France where Nelly’s ‘Hot in Herre’ could come on and the crowd would roar, and then The White Stripes’ ‘Seven Nation Army’ could come on and the crowd would roar even louder. The two records have nothing in common. The crowd didn’t care. Everyone there already knew both, and most of them, I’d guess, had never gone looking for either.

They didn’t need to. The songs had got there first, through MTV and the other music channels, the radio, the car, the shop, the school disco, the chart everyone followed whether they meant to or not. You didn’t have to like a song to know it. You only had to leave the house.

Read that way, the second comment’s ‘peak’ isn’t something an artist does alone. It’s what happens when a song has already been through every one of those places, and a club full of strangers finds out they all know the same chorus.

None of this was innocent. MTV, radio and the charts were selling hard, and plenty of those records were as manufactured as anything made now. The difference is that everyone got sold the same thing.

Closer to home it was sillier. My Dad would turn up Missy Elliott’s ‘Get Ur Freak On’ in the car and insist she was singing ‘get your free cone’. He had the backstory ready: she’d been an ice-cream lady. Years later he heard Ed Sheeran’s ‘Shape of You’ and sang, with exactly the same confidence, ‘my bedsheets smell like poo’.

Both jokes only work if the other person knows the song. By the second one there were fewer songs you could bank on. There were still a few.

When Facebook and YouTube arrived, posting a music video felt like the old habit by other means. I heard this; now you hear it. For a while people answered. Then they stopped. Posting a song started to feel like talking to an empty room, and then, worse, like setting homework. Playing friends a favourite playlist at their house and getting almost nothing back brought a peculiar disappointment, wildly out of proportion to anything at stake. Looking back, I think I was trying to do by hand what the nightclub used to do for free: I heard something, now you hear it, now it’s ours.

The pop song used to belong to the room. Now it belongs to the account. Spotify, YouTube and the recommendations behind them are good at giving each listener more of what that listener already likes. The better they get, the less anyone stumbles into anyone else’s music. People may well listen to more than ever and share less of it.

The old system needed a song that could take over a room; the new one needs one listener not to skip.

What’s gone isn’t good music. It’s the songs everybody knew without anybody choosing them.

I don’t think the apps did this on their own. Television split the same way, and the news. Music was one more place where everyone got a version built to their own taste.

The shift I feel, somewhere around 2011 and 2012, lines up with my own adolescence and with streaming becoming the main way people listened to music. The two arrived together and I can’t pull them apart. Everyone’s music was best when they were young. Both those comments could be the same bias talking. So could this.

The bias can make old songs sound better. It doesn’t explain why people stopped answering when I posted a song, or the silence after the playlist. And ‘Genie in a Bottle’ hasn’t changed. It’s the same recording people called soulless pop crap, and back then they heard it alongside everyone else. If it sounds rich now, some of that richness may be the crowd that used to come with it.

The old arrangement had no opt-out. It played you songs you hated in shops you hadn’t wanted to go into, and you learned some of them by heart anyway. That part never went away. Shops still play you songs you didn’t pick. They’re just worse songs.

Which leaves a question for anyone who was ever in a nightclub like that one, and for anyone who never was: what would a crowd of strangers roar for now, together, without anyone having picked it?